Justice for All
 Church in Decline
 Striking Similarity
 The Efficacy of Prayer
 Are You Ready for Change?
 A Question of Vocation
 The Challenge of Change
 Elul 24
 Elul 23
 Elul 22

Series [All]
 Elul 5777 (9)
 Exploring Translation Theories (25)
 Live Like You Give a Damn
 Memory and Identity
 The Creative Word (19)
 The Cross-Cultural Process (7)
 The Old Testament is Dying
 The Oral Gospel Tradition (4)
 We the People (8)


Friday, 18 December 2015

A Question of Contradictions

Unity and Diversity in Christ: Interpreting Paul in Context: Collected Essays,
Willian S. Campbell, Cascade Books, 2013, page 73

The older Lutheran view of Paul and the shiny "New Perspective" introduce a scholarly conflict. Campbell puts it this way:

The conflict surrounding the question of contradictions in Paul's thought arises mainly from a debate as to what constitutes the "real Paul". Is he the heroic Paul who is depicted as the champion of the gentiles or is the "revised Paul" of Romans, especially of Romans 11? To put it another way: is the real Paul to be identified with the previous pro-gentile image of the apostle, or with the more recent Jewish Paul identified in Romans, particularly in chapters 9-11? Is the apostle really pro-gentile (partial to gentiles and their cause) or is his gospel "to the Jew first and also the gentile" (inclusive and impartial)?

How too might the canonical process play into this? If the older view - that Romans 9-11 is something of a now irrelevant parenthetical block, written simply for people at the time - has been "blessed" and "approved" by the community that has been preserving and interpreting the text for the last 1900 years, does that make it the canonical interpretation and therefore in any way immutable?

Or, as has been recently put to me by a scholar of some repute, is Paul's "to the Jew first and also the gentile" actually showing deliberate preference to theJews, bringing the gentiles up to join them, but marking the Jews for priority in line with G-d's first and ancient choice of the Jewish people?

Posted By Jonathan, 9:29am Comment Comments: